Katch Invest

Growth & Momentum Everywhere

Growth & Momentum Everywhere

3d newton cradle
By Laurent Jeanmart - Katch Investment Group Chairman

In 2009, Clifford Asness, Tobias Moskowitz and Lasse Pedersen published a paper titled “Value and momentum everywhere”. The rationale behind their analysis was simple: value bias investing generates returns that are lowly, or even negatively correlated with a “momentum” style of investing. Value investors invest in stocks that are fundamentally cheap, whereas momentum investors allocate capital on the basis that what has gone up should continue to go up. Diversify your portfolio across stocks exhibiting a value profile and others that have had strong momentum behind them, and you will likely generate better risk-adjusted returns than investing in either of these styles in isolation. The sweet spot is in finding stocks that combine both styles. This is perhaps why Apple has been a hedge fund darling for so long: it has been showing lower than average cash flow, earnings and sales multiples that competitors and the broader market while enjoying a powerful momentum that propelled its share price up by a factor of 25 in 10 years. 

Intuitively, this approach makes sense: if a stock is cheap and starts to go up, perhaps it is on its way to correct its cheapness. If that is the case, it should outperform peers and the broader market once this is corrected. Also, financial practitioners know that sources of diversification inequities are rare, and anything that lowers the risk of one’s portfolio while keeping its expected return constant is worth having. In combining value and momentum, a portfolio manager can have his cake and eat it. That is the theory.

However, and rather sadly, this beautiful concept finds substantial limitations in everyday investing. We find that value as a style works well, but only if the investment window reaches several years – at least according to professor Robert Schiller of Yale, who argues that the minimum window of value investments should be 8 years, with better results for those willing to invest over a period twice as long. Besides, as pointed out by Israel and Moskowitz at AQR Capital, a large US-based asset management firm run by Asness himself, value only offers a long-term premium when applied to very small stocks. 

Alongside Kent Daniel, a scholar at the Kellogg School of Management, we find that the growth style of investing combines with momentum much better than value to generate excess returns. Consider this: a portfolio of the stocks that rank highest according to momentum and value metrics has generated 100 bps of excess performance over the S&P500 in the last 10 years. This, however, comes with a larger maximum drawdown: -55.5%, vs. -52.6% for the S&P500. By contrast, a growth and momentum portfolio of 10 stocks has beaten the S&P500 by an average of approximately 18 percentage points per annum over the same period. This also comes with a lower maximum drawdown (-41.8%).

Beyond the practical implications of the shortcomings of investing by combining value and momentum, we believe at Katch that the prism through which Asness & al. look at these issues is symptomatic of the faulty way the financial community addresses these issues. We believe that drawdown, and not volatility, is the true measure of risk. This is because our investors care much more about the risk of losing a large chunk of their capital (“drawdown risk”) than the day-to-day gyrations of capital markets (“volatility”). No offense to Mr. Asness, but since combining value and momentum does reduce the volatility of a portfolio but not its drawdown risk, it is of little practical interest to us. Momentum does that in isolation, as an enormous amount of literature has repeatedly shown, and we see little upside in polluting its benefits by combining it with a value filter.

By accessing this website content, you agree to be bound by the conditions.

It is important that you read the following page before proceeding, as it explains certain legal and regulatory restrictions applicable to the distribution of this information. By accessing any content of this website, you agree to be bound by the conditions. If you do not agree to the conditions, please exit the website. Neither Katch Investment Group; Katch Fund Solutions – Global Lending Opportunities Fund, Katch Fund Solutions – Real Estate Lending Fund, or Katch Fund Solutions – Factoring Fund (the “Funds”) will be responsible for any misrepresentations you may make in gaining unauthorized access. It is your responsibility to inform yourself of and to observe all applicable laws and regulations of the relevant jurisdiction. This website content is intended to be for information purposes only and it is not intended as promotional material in any respect. The information contained in this website (including marketing presentations, factsheets, and articles) does not constitute a distribution, an offer to sell or the solicitation of an offer to buy any securities in any jurisdiction in which such offer or invitation is not authorized and/or would be contrary to local law or regulation. This website is not intended for any “U.S. Person” as defined in the Prospectus. For more information write us at info@katchinvest.com. The information contained on this site, and on downloadable materials is believed to be accurate at the date of publication, but no warranty of accuracy is given, and the information is subject to change without notice. Any opinions or estimates included herein constitute a judgment as of this date and are subject to change without notice. If you are in any doubt about the information contained herein please consult your stockbroker, solicitor, accountant, bank manager or other professional adviser. All content and information are being made available free of charge. By proceeding you agree to the exclusion of any liability in respect of any errors or omissions contained in it. No liability is accepted by any person within Katch Investment Group or the Funds for any losses or damage arising from the use or reliance on the information contained herein including, without limitation, any loss of profit, or any other damage direct or consequential.

Investment in emerging market involves risk factors and special considerations which may not be typically associated with investing in more developed markets. Political or economic change and instability may be more likely to occur and have a greater effect on the economies and markets of emerging countries. Adverse government policies, taxation, restrictions on foreign investment and on currency convertibility and repatriation, currency fluctuations and other developments in the laws and regulations of emerging countries in which investment may be made, including expropriation, nationalization or other confiscation could result in loss to the Funds. The risk factors referred to above are not an exhaustive list and reference should be made to the relevant Prospectus. The value of investments and the income from them may go down as well as up and you may not get back your original investment. The Funds are intended for sophisticated investors who can accept the risks associated with such an investment including a substantial or complete loss of their investment. Past performance is not necessarily a guide to future performance. A person within Katch Investment Group and/or Katch Fund Solutions, its affiliates, their directors and the investment funds/accounts it manages may or may not have a position in or with respect to any securities mentioned herein.This website is solely reserved to investors that are located in France and defined as Professional Investors as per the AIFM Directive, or investors that are located in Switzerland and defined as Well-Informed Investors as per the Luxembourg act of 23 July 2016 on reserved alternative funds.

Special note for investors in Switzerland: Home country of the Fund: Luxembourg. The representative in Switzerland is 1741 Fund Solutions AG, Burggraben 16, CH-9000 St. Gallen. The Swiss Paying Agent in Switzerland is Tellco LTD, Bahnhofstrasse 4, 6430 Schwyz, Switzerland. The offering memorandum and other key investor information document or fund contract as well as the annual reports may be obtained free of charge from the representative. In respect of the units distributed in and from Switzerland, the place of performance and jurisdiction is the registered office of the Representative.

If you have read, understood, and accepted above conditions, you can enter.